Bookends is a New York Times Book Review column in which two writers write about one topic from two perspectives. This week’s column is: Why Do Debut Novels Command So Much Attention? Leslie Jamison compares the appeal of debut novelists to the NBA draft and suggests that reading debuts gives readers, “the chance to read an author before she has become a legacy.” Ayana Mathis looks at the weight of the debut, and delves into the extent to which, “a debut novel is a piece of the writer’s soul in a way that subsequent books can’t ever quite be.”
Both pieces offer lucid insights into the power of the debut and acknowledge that for every debut that gets a big advance there are many worthy books that never sell, nor make it into bookstores. The two views provide insightful looks into why the debut novel is such a marketable book—as either the next hip book to read and talk about at a party, or the book that the author needed to write to feel fulfilled.